Skip to content
SEO & GEO

30 Questions to Ask an SEO Agency Before You Sign

Thirty questions to ask an SEO agency before you sign, grouped into seven areas, with what a good answer includes and the red flag to watch for.

Louis Mauclair · CEO

Updated November 2026 · 9 min read

30 questions à poser à une agence SEO avant de signer

TL;DR Before you sign with an SEO agency, ask 30 questions across seven areas: your business, the team, the method, deliverables, GEO, the contract, and the plan if results lag. For each one, this guide shows what a good answer includes and the red flag that should end the conversation. A serious agency answers with names, numbers and documents. A weak one answers with promises. Google says it plainly: no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.

By Louis Mauclair, CEO of Klickbee, an SEO, GEO and Google Ads agency for B2B and ecommerce companies. Before Klickbee, he co-⁠founded an ecommerce business that grew past 13,000 customers.

Most lists of questions to ask an SEO agency look the same: "Do you have references?" "What tools do you use?" Any agency can answer those. What matters is knowing a good answer when you hear one. So this is an interview scorecard. If you need selection criteria and a side-⁠by-⁠side comparison grid instead, read our guide on how to choose an SEO agency.

The starting point comes from Google itself. In its "Do you need an SEO?" page, Google tells site owners to interview potential SEOs and to check that they are genuinely interested in your business. It also lists warning signs: guaranteed rankings, a claimed "special relationship" with Google, cold emails out of the blue, and secrecy about what they plan to do.

Questions about your business (market, buyers, sales cycle)

1. What do you understand about our market and our customers?

  • Good answer: a sharp summary of your offer, your buyers and your competitors, prepared before the call.
  • Red flag: a generic pitch about "more traffic" that would fit a florist as well as an equipment manufacturer.

2. Which keywords would you target, and why those?

  • Good answer: queries tied to buying intent, ranked by business value, with sourced search volumes.
  • Red flag: a list of high-⁠volume keywords that have nothing to do with what you sell.

3. How does SEO fit into our sales cycle?

  • Good answer: for B2B, content for each stage (problem, comparison, decision) and lead tracking all the way into your CRM.
  • Red flag: they never ask about deal size, sales cycle length, or what a qualified lead means to you.

4. What experience do you have in our industry and our target countries?

  • Good answer: comparable case studies, and a clear plan for each language or market. Google lists this exact question.
  • Red flag: "SEO is the same everywhere." A machine-⁠translated site is not an international strategy.

Questions about the team (who does the work, seniority, turnover)

5. Who will actually work on our account?

  • Good answer: names, roles, and a number of hours or deliverables per month.
  • Red flag: the senior strategist from the sales call disappears after you sign.

6. How senior is the person leading our strategy?

  • Good answer: someone who has run projects your size and stays your main contact.
  • Red flag: a junior account manager juggling 30 clients.

7. What happens if that person leaves?

  • Good answer: shared documentation (strategy, change log) that makes a handoff painless.
  • Red flag: everything lives in one consultant's head.

8. How much of the work is done with AI tools, and who reviews it?

  • Good answer: AI helps with research and structure, and a human expert checks every piece. That matches Google's own guidance, which calls AI useful for adding structure to original content.
  • Red flag: "50 blog posts a month" at a bargain price with no expert review. Google says generating many pages without adding value may violate its scaled content abuse policy.

Questions about the method and the 90-day plan

9. What will you do in the first 90 days?

  • Good answer: a dated plan: audit, priority technical fixes, first pages, tracking setup.
  • Red flag: "We start with an audit and go from there." An audit with no roadmap is just a PDF.

10. What do you tackle first, and why?

  • Good answer: priorities ranked by impact and effort, based on your site (see our approach to SEO strategy).
  • Red flag: the same plan for every client.

11. Do you follow Google Search Essentials?

  • Good answer: yes, with examples of what they refuse to do. Google includes this question in its own list.
  • Red flag: hesitation, or vague talk about "advanced techniques" they can't explain.
  • Good answer: digital PR, reference content and partnerships, with a separate budget and a site list if any links are paid (see our guide on how to get backlinks).
  • Red flag: private blog networks, repurposed expired domains, hundreds of links a month. Google's spam policies name buying links for ranking purposes and expired domain abuse.

13. Which technical fixes can you implement yourselves?

  • Good answer: a clear split between what the agency ships and what needs your developer, with specific tickets.
  • Red flag: recommendations nobody implements for six months.

Questions about deliverables and reporting

14. What exactly do we get each month?

  • Good answer: a number of pages created or optimized, a list of fixes, a report. In writing, in the proposal.
  • Red flag: "Ongoing optimization," with no volume attached.

15. Which metrics do you report on?

  • Good answer: rankings and traffic, plus leads, demo requests or revenue from organic search.
  • Red flag: a report that only tracks rankings on keywords the agency picked.

16. How much of our team's time will you need?

  • Good answer: an honest estimate: subject-⁠matter interviews, approvals, developer time.
  • Red flag: "None, we handle everything." B2B expert content without your expertise stays shallow.

17. How often do we talk, and with whom?

  • Good answer: a monthly call with the strategist and a channel for urgent issues. Google also suggests asking how you can expect to communicate.
  • Red flag: an automated report in your inbox with nobody to walk you through it.

18. What access do you need?

  • Good answer: user access to your accounts (Search Console, Analytics, CMS) while you stay the owner. Google notes that a removed owner can re-⁠verify if their verification token is still in place.
  • Red flag: the agency sets up accounts under its own name or won't give you owner access.

19. How do you measure our visibility in ChatGPT, Perplexity and AI Overviews?

  • Good answer: a tracked set of prompts checked monthly, including which sources the AI cites. That is the core of GEO.
  • Red flag: "You can't measure AI." Or the opposite: a promise to "get you cited by ChatGPT."

20. What changes in your approach because of AI answers?

  • Good answer: pages that answer clearly, sourced proof, and presence on the sites AI engines cite. The stakes are real: Pew Research found users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, versus 15% without one (July 2025).
  • Red flag: nothing changes, or everything changes and classic SEO gets dropped.

21. Do we need an llms.txt file or special markup for AI?

  • Good answer: a nuanced one. Google says it doesn't use llms.txt and that no special files or markup are needed to appear in its generative AI features.
  • Red flag: a paid "AI optimization" add-⁠on that boils down to uploading a file.

22. How do you connect GEO to pipeline?

  • Good answer: tracking of referral traffic from AI assistants and a "how did you hear about us?" field on your forms.
  • Red flag: screenshots of citations with no link to sales.

Questions about the contract and exit terms

23. How long is the commitment, and what is the notice period?

  • Good answer: three to six months to give SEO time to work, then short notice. For price benchmarks, see our guide to SEO pricing.
  • Red flag: a locked 12-month term with auto-⁠renewal.

24. What is included, and what is not?

  • Good answer: a written list: content, technical work, link building, tools.
  • Red flag: link building or copywriting turns out to be an add-⁠on after you sign.

25. Who owns the content and the data?

  • Good answer: you do, from delivery, including if you leave.
  • Red flag: pages hosted on the agency's domain, or content you only "rent."

26. What do we get back if we cancel?

  • Good answer: the strategy, the change log, the tracking files, and every account access returned.
  • Red flag: they have no answer, or they charge for the handoff.

27. Can we talk to a current client?

  • Good answer: yes, with an introduction, or at least detailed case studies with a timeframe and a business result.
  • Red flag: a wall of logos and no one you can call.

What if the results don't show up?

28. What results do you expect, and on what timeline?

  • Good answer: realistic milestones: fixes and first pages, then rankings, then leads. Google recommends asking exactly this.
  • Red flag: "Page one in 30 days, guaranteed." Google's words: no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.

29. What do you do if metrics are flat at month three?

  • Good answer: a written diagnosis (technical, content, competition) and a revised plan.
  • Red flag: "SEO takes time," with no analysis.

30. When would you tell us not to hire you?

  • Good answer: a straight answer: a site mid-⁠rebuild, a market too small, a need that Google Ads would serve better.
  • Red flag: they have never turned down a client.

Bottom line: questions to ask an SEO agency are a comparison tool

These 30 questions to ask an SEO agency are not a trap. They let you compare agencies on written answers instead of gut feeling. Use the same scorecard for every call, and ask for the key commitments to appear in the proposal.

Here are our own answers: senior strategists backed by in-⁠house AI agents, a bilingual English and French team, a 3-month minimum then 1-month notice, and every account and page in your name. Details are on our B2B SEO agency page. To see how we work before you sign anything, request your free action plan, delivered in 48 hours.

FAQ

What are the 4 pillars of SEO?

They're usually listed as technical SEO (crawling, indexing, speed), content, authority (links) and user experience. A good agency tells you which pillar is holding your site back right now.

What are the 3 types of SEO?

On-⁠page SEO (content and tags), off-⁠page SEO (links and mentions) and technical SEO. Ask the agency who handles each one, and with what budget.

Can an SEO agency guarantee a #1 ranking on Google?

No. Google's documentation states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and advises finding someone else if an SEO promises one.

How many questions should I ask on the first call?

About ten is enough for a first call: market, team, 90-day plan, deliverables and contract. Save the rest for the follow-⁠up, once you have the proposal.

Sources

Share

LinkedInX

Louis Mauclair

Louis leads growth and digital acquisition for B2B and e-⁠commerce companies in France and the UAE. Before Klickbee, he co-⁠built and sold an e-⁠commerce business that served more than 13,000 customers. He moved to Dubai in 2026 to work with companies across the GCC.

Free action plan

Want more leads from your traffic?

Get your 6-page action plan within 48 hours.

Get my free action plan

Related articles

All articles

Free action plan

Grow faster. Get your free action plan.

A tailored plan to generate more leads and sales from your existing traffic.

  • Built for B2B & e-⁠commerce teams
  • No commitment
  • A 15-minute call, then your plan within 48 hours
  • ★ 5.0 on Google · 22 reviews
  • Senior experts + in-⁠house AI
  • Founders of a 13,000-customer e-⁠commerce

Your action plan

6 pages · 3 priority levers · within 48 h

Free

Step 1 of 2 — Your business

Got a question first? Message us on WhatsApp
Get my free action planWhatsApp